You may want to sit back and relax, and perhaps even grab a bite to eat before you read any further. I’m about to share with you the tale of one of the top 5 meals I’ve ever eaten.
So, comfy? Well fed? Ok, here goes…
Once upon a time, there was this guy named Joel Palmer, and he lived in Indiana. It was around 1845 that he got bored with things there and decided to head out west and see what all the fuss was about. As it turns out, Joel was pretty well suited to frontier life and the pioneering lifestyle, qualities that greatly benefited several of the wagon trains he led. He was pretty hardcore, too – climbed Mt. Hood in the middle of winter in freakin’ moccassins, and discovered the Barlow Pass.
Joel was a statesman, diplomat, adventurer and was pretty much the real-life Chuck Norris of his day, and in the middle of all of his adventuring and diplomating and things, he built this house.
Fast forward to 1996. Jack Czarnecki bought the house and turned it into a restaurant, and built a reputation for excellent food and service in a relaxed fine-dining atmosphere. About 5 years ago, Jack decided he wanted to spend more time in the hills and woods of Oregon hunting for wild mushrooms and truffles (side note: Oregon truffles are held as equals with their European cousins in many culinary circles), and his son Chris had been gradually assuming more responsibilities in and out of the kitchen, so it was a natural and seamless passing of the torch when Chris took over in 2009.
Which brings us to June 2010. Megan had taken a trip to see her ocean. She loves the Oregon Coast. I flew up on a Friday to meet her and drive home together. Now, I have often lamented the fact that Megan experienced what a truffle was before I did, and that she has actually enjoyed them several times without me while I had never had the pleasure. That’s just wrong. So, as soon as I had gotten into the car at the airport, Megan asked me if I was hungry.
Seriously?
Well, bless her ever-loving heart, she had been on the internet looking for restaurants that served truffles, having heard that Oregon truffles were every bit as good as the European ones, and had stumbled across the Joel Palmer House, which just happened to be right along the way of our two-hour drive from Portland to the coast. I was giddy with anticipation (and probably a fair portion of hunger as well).
When we pulled up, I felt woefully under dressed in my jeans and hoodie, and although the other diners varied in dress from my level of casual to a jacket and tie somewhat more suited to a fine dining establishment, the hostess and staff made us feel right at home and perfectly comfortable.
It bears mentioning that everything at the Joel Palmer House is mushroom-centric – the wild mushrooms and truffles that Jack forages are the staple of their menu – but even if you think you don’t like mushrooms, I am confident that their menu will surprise and delight you if you are willing to be adventurous to even the slightest degree.
The hostess let us know that they served in the European style, which meant that we didn’t have an assigned server, but that every member of the staff was at our disposal. The Somelier arrived at our table shortly after we were seated and I chose a glass of Pinot Grigio, which was excellent.
For appetizers, I ordered the Foie Gras and Porcini Ravioli with Port-Reduction and Black Truffles, and Megan had the Three Mushroom Tart, which is a Palmer House Specialty.
When I was telling Stefahn about our experince after we had returned home, he let me know that I was an asshole for ordering Foie Gras. I don’t care, it was delicious and perfect – the flavors worked together so brilliantly that there didn’t seem to be any transition between the layers of sweet and savory goodness and delicate texture of the ravioli and filling, but more a gentle progression as smooth as the tide coming in on an Oregon beach. It was heavenly.
And I was transfixed by my own appetizer until I made the mistake of sampling the mushroom tart Megan had ordered. It was, as she put it, the single best food she’s ever eaten. It came in a very close second for me, nearly eclipsing the Potatoes Au Gratin at the Ritz-Carlton in Naples. Delicious doesn’t begin to describe the experience. It was rich and savory, and had the texture of a superbly tender meat pie. The crust was light and flaky, as close to perfection as I’ve ever had, and although there was a very definite earthiness that you would expect from a tart made entirely of mushrooms, it was a balanced and deep flavor, not overwhelmingly “mushroom-y” in it’s presence.
In fact, it was so absolutely perfect that I requested the chef at our table. Chris appeared promptly, and I asked (understanding the long-held tradition of closely guarding recipe secrets) if he would be willing to share the recipe. His surprising reply was “sure! Hang on one second.” He turned back into the kitchen, and returned a few moments later with a card containing the recipe, which he presented to me. He then spent the next few minutes explaining his method and a few of his particular ways of preparing the tart so that it turned out perfectly. I thanked him wholeheartedly, congratulating him on such culinary brilliance, and returned to the meal.
Both Megan and I chose the Filet Mignon of Painted Hills Beef served with Szechwan Pepper Porcini Sauce. I don’t know if I can say it was the best filet I’ve ever had, simply because the field is separated by such a narrow margin. I mean, is filet’s were an Olympic event, the top 10 filets I’ve ever eaten would be separated by mere thousandth’s of a second, and the filet Chris prepared for us was easily in that field – tender, juicy, flavorful and expertly seared. The Pepper Porcini sauce was, by design I’m sure, a glorious compliment to the cut - rich and savory, with an ever-so-slight heat that enhanced the natural flavor of the meat.
To finish things off, Megan ordered the house-made concord grape sorbet, which was a fantastic experience of sweet and tart, very much akin to eating frozen concord grapes, I’m sure. On the dessert menu I noticed a mushroom ice cream, and my curiosity got the better of me. As it turns out, I;m glad it did! The single scoop of pale mocha colored nirvana arrived, and at the first taste, I was enveloped by tastes of caramel and rum (although it contains neither), gently supported by the underlying subtle earthiness of the porcini mushrooms used to make this divinely inspired concoction. I can say no more than this: it was the perfect ending to an excellent meal.
Chris visited our table once again, and he and I talked for about 15 minutes or so (a generous allowance for a chef to give any guest!), and he shared more of his kitchen secrets and methods, and was as candid and charming as any man I’ve ever met. It’s clear that Chef Chris has a passion for what he does, and his love of his craft shows on the plate as well as the warmth of the entire experience.
If you find yourself anywhere within several hundred miles of the Joel Palmer House, it’s worth whatever effort may be required to make a visit.
Hell, it’s almost worth the14 hour drive to me right now.