After my last post on The Greatest Stuff in the World, one of my friends suggested I try the minestrone soup at Zucca Trattoria in South Ogden, claiming it was sincerely the best minestrone in the world. I recently took him up on his offer and went to dinner with he and his sweetheart.
I was a little surprised at the location of what my friend had hailed as (and Zucca’s website had also purported to be) a fine dining restaurant. It’s on the corner of a lonely strip mall about a mile off US 89 in a rather sparse part of South Ogden. Withholding my judgments until I’d sampled Chef Elio Scanu’s creations, I held the door for my wife as we stepped inside and were immediately welcomed by subtle and pleasant aromas of skilled artisans meticulously creating culinary bliss. We were seated promptly by a very friendly hostess, and our server arrived shortly after to take our drink orders. My friend decided on a glass of red wine (I don’t remember what kind, as I’m not a fan of the reds) and I selected a glass of the Pinot Grigio.
While waiting for our drinks, I couldn’t help but notice that as much as they’d tried to create an atmosphere of warmth and relaxed refinement, the large windows that made up the east wall of the building were a dead giveaway of the reality that we were dining in a strip mall. Kinda ruined it a bit for me, to tell you the truth, but again, I was here to have the best minestrone in the world, not to enjoy the ambience.
Our drinks arrived with appetizers of beef carpaccio with lemon-basil aioli and truffle oil and a plate of tempura-style shrimp and calamari. Although I’m generally not a fan of seafood, I did sample the prawns, which were excellent – tender, moist and flavorful with no need for cocktail sauce. The carpaccio was equally excellent – paper thin and so tender it almost fell apart on the fork. After thoroughly enjoying the appetizer, I felt like my friend may have been justified in his appraisal of the soup and was genuinely looking forward to the next course.
My minestrone arrived, and although I was not disappointed (it truly was a revelation), I don’t know if I can go so far as to call it the best in the world. The pasta was perfectly cooked, the broth was rich and flavorful, the beans were firm but tender, and the vegetables still had just a touch of crispness to them – it was an excellent soup, to be sure. That being said, I sampled some of my friends tomato basil bisque, which was rich and creamy, and absolutely perfect. Perhaps it was just my mood, but as wonderful as the minestrone was, I would have enjoyed the tomato basil even more.
Our entrees arrived, and were as beautiful as they were tasty. Megan had ordered the mushroom risotto for her meal (which at $15 felt a bit overpriced), I had the filet which was cooked to a near-perfect rare and served with wilted spinach and a balsamic reduction. I don’t know that most balsamic vinegars lend themselves to a reduction, as they tend to be quite robust in their flavors to begin with. By reducing what was a very well-balanced balsamic, Chef Scanu had further intensified the already strong flavors to a point just this side of overwhelming. I touched my exquisitely tender filet to the reduction sparingly and delicately, which may very well have been the chef’s intention. It was delicious and succulent as any filet I’ve ever had.
I did sample my friend’s seared ahi, which was equally brilliant. Had Zucca not offered a filet, I almost certainly would have selected the sushi-grade ahi steak. The sear on it was textbook, penetrating only 1/8th of an inch and leaving the rest of the cut perfectly uncooked. There was no fishiness to it, but instead a delicate flavor of herbs that was a brilliant compliment to the firm texture of the fish. In spite of the fact that it was a fish, it was superb.
For dessert, we chose crème brulée and tiramisu. The tiramisu was perfect in every way, although the coffee flavor was quite mild. As a man who enjoys a very bold and strong coffee in his cup, I would have enjoyed a more robust flavor. The crème brulée was a bit of a disappointment, as it had a very grainy texture which is usually the sign of cooking the custard too fast or too hot – either of which is an unpardonable offense for a chef of Scanu’s caliber.
Overall it was a fantastic experience, although given the sub-par dessert and the dischordant ambience, ever so slightly overpriced. I’ll certainly eat there again, as I enjoyed the food (and the company) and our server was very attentive without being obtrusive, which is very important to me, but I’m likely to entertain other options before settling on Zucca for a second visit.