Let me begin this post by making one thing very clear: this is not an attack on the LDS faith, it’s members or it’s leaders. I bear the church no ill-will. I’m not a bitter ex-mormon lashing out at church leaders, or anything of the kind.
That said, I have a real issue with the LDS church encouraging their members to support Proposition 8, and even going so far as to encourage their members who are residents or former residents of California to call their friends and family who reside in the state encouraging them to support Prop 8. Seriously, here’s the press release. Legal experts say that this hasn’t yet crossed the line of church and state. Technically, the actions of the LDS Church are still supported by the First Amendment.
For those of you who haven’t been following the news, Proposition 8 is a measure on the ballot in California to amend their constitution specifying that “marriage” is only legal if it’s between a man and a woman. You see, earlier this year, the California Supreme Court ruled that the statute enacted by Proposition 22 in March of 2000, as well as other statutes that limit marriage to a relationship between a man and a woman, violated the equal protection clause of the California Constitution. It also held that individuals of the same sex have the right to marry under the California Constitution. As a result of the ruling, marriage between individuals of the same sex is currently valid or recognized in the state of California.
Proposition 8 will change the California Constitution (not just the statute, or governing law) to clearly specify that you can only be “married” if one of you is a dude and the other is a girl.
Now, let me just reiterate before I go on my tirade in just a moment here: this is not an attack on the LDS faith, it’s members or it’s leaders.
Rant begins here.
In order to discuss this rationally and logically, which the great majority of people (on both sides) fail to do, let’s first consider what “marriage” actually is. A Google search of “Marriage” yields roughly 181 million results, so it’s pretty safe to say there’s plenty of information out there. Webster defines marriage as both “the state of being united to a person of the opposite sex as husband or wife in a consensual and contractual relationship” and “the state of being united to a person of the same sex in a relationship”
So, from a strictly legal standpoint, a civil union – regardless of the make-up, be it boy/boy, boy/girl, girl/girl or anything your imagination might dream up – exists if two people have entered into a consensual and contractual relationship. In short, they’re married. Pretty basic, right?
Hardly.
You see, marriage is not just a civil and legal matter, but a religious one as well. In fact, in many religions, marriage is held as sacred, and ceremonies, sacraments and celebrations surround the actual event. This is all well and good, until one starts to blur the lines between religion and state.
Now I don’t personally believe that it’s any of the governments business who I hold hands with. If someone chooses to marry their pet iguana or a lamp, what do I care? For you hardcore activists out there who will no doubt cry foul and bring issues of taxation and partner benefits, I say only this: if the insurance agency wishes to extend partner benefits or withhold them, that’s their business, not the governments. As for the taxation, does an iguana or a lamp have income? Then what is there to be taxed?
So here’s the part of this whole thing that just angers me beyond reason. The LDS church is encouraging it’s members to not only support Prop 8, but to donate money to the campaign and to actively proselyte the cause to their friends and relatives.
It’s one thing for a church to take a position that marriage (within their respective religion) is between a man and a woman. It’s another issue entirely when the government is either dragged into the mix or intervenes willingly to mandate this same religious standard for every person in their jurisdiction, regardless of faith.
I’m not the only one who feels that the LDS church has crossed a line, here. In fact, Bruce Bastian, co-founder of WordPerfect and an ex-mormon, on hearing that the LDS church had encouraged it’s members to “do all you can” to back Prop 8 and had organized fund-raising efforts to support it, donated $1 million of his own money to fight against it. Incidentally, his contribution easily eclipsed the total from fundraising efforts conducted by church members, which amounted to roughly $120,000.
One of the basic tenets of the LDS faith is free agency – the right to choose and be accountable for those choices. It seems more than a little hypocritical to proclaim free agency and at the same time fight to limit the choices of others who may or may not share your belief. After all, didn’t the LDS church members fight a pretty similar fight in their early days, but on the other side, fighting for the freedom to be LDS when everyone around was fighting to take away that choice?
Intersting how time changes things.